Pizza, the Way It’s Supposed to Be!
An homage to Gus Guerra, the father of Detroit-style pizza, and all the great Detroit pizza joints, our Mackinac Island pizzeria is Motown through and through.
With house-proofed Sicilian dough, topped with cheese, tomato sauce, and — dare we say, even occasionally your other favorite ingredients — our pan pies are produced fresh daily in the very same deep-dish square pans that make Detroit pizza, well…Detroit. The thick steel pans deliver a uniquely crunchy but light crust, perfectly prepared oven-baked toppings, and the caramelized cheese edges that hold it all together.
We may not have any cars on the Island, but we have Motown and even a square to spare!
Mackinac Island Pizza Company
1547 Cadotte Avenue
906-847-2313
Mackinac Island Pizza Company is closed for the 2024 season. Please check back for dining hours when the 2025 season opens April 25, 2005. We look forward to seeing you next season!